Day 5

Yes. The Seer just sees him as Evil.

 

Yeah

 

How the feck does that work?

What's the point of the seer then?

 

it doesn't, Realised it the second I posted. Utter brain fart. Was hoping to stealth edit redaction before anyone saw.

And this also proves SLB is Good.

 

It still does not. The Wolf just picked on SLB as he thought the Seer HAD picked an actual EVIL, so named anyone with the odds being in his favour that he wouldn't pick a wolf.

The lack of anyone else coming forward as a Harlot is still the only thing keeping SLB safe.

 

Ok so this is the point I've been making.

Day 2 msg 1 - Daft Row is evil.
Day 2 msg 2 - SLB is evil

So 1st message is the wolf - 2nd message is the seer.

The harlot wouldn't be seen as evil.

I'm done and I don't care...I'm voting SLB everyday.

 

I find it strangely baffling that Hornetgags is so confused by the Tinker after the whole issue the last game.

 

PJ protecting SLB with a tenuous argument.

These 2, as far as I'm concerened are evil.

 

Wrong. day 2 msg 1 was Seer. Saw DR as EVIL as was the Tinker and ultimately voted for him.

I'm going hornetgags suddenly. This whole baffled by the Tinker is not sitting right.

 

I'm also defending SLB with a massive argument. In my mind SLB is 99.9% Harlot. If not then this whole game was lost by the real Harlot not coming forward on Day 2.

So with overwhelming evidence to show SLB is probably the Harlot, you are still going for him every day??? Unless SLB is a Wolf Harlot (which would be really unfair Harrow!!!!!) then your reasoning is flimsy.

 

My post from two days ago, which bit don't you understand?

 

Why's that? All I remember about the last game was I was the last good to be killed.

I don't really know what the tinker does, this only my 3rd game and still don't really understand it. All I see is spurious and tenuous arguments put forward and the domino effect in terms of voting.

I'm going on this (like it or lump it - but tell me where my logic is flawed and I'll gladly withdraw)

Day 2 msg 1 - Daft Row is evil (couldn't give a flying feck if he's the tinker or not) - when he died he was declared GOOD
Day 2 msg 2 - SLB is evil - same day so it had to be from the seer - the harlot is seen as good.

That's my logic - again tell me where I'm wrong based on that.

 

Flimsy how? You're convinced he's the harlot...I'm not.

 

Wrong. Both the same day.

 

I'm really not sure if you're not getting it or you're trying to save steve harrow. The logic is plain. Otter's post pointed it all out. I've tried to explain it. I'm sure others have too. All are pretty simple explanations but you are adamantly against it... too adamantly against it???

If you just don't understand the tinker role then why are you adamantly not accepting our explanations which are based in a hell of a lot of evidence? Yet you ignore us and still go for SLB?

 

By the way, after no other Harlot came forward and we started assuming SLB was the Harlot, day 3 both you and Steve Harrow voted SLB.

 

You're smelling like the traitor, if I'm honest:

Let me out you like this:

Link for day 2:

http://wfcforums.com/index.php?threads/summer-werewolf-ii-day-2.52859/

Post #15

Ok everybody, I know the first day is difficult. People need to remember that shouting accusations about doesn't help anybody at this stage. Today I decided to view DAFT ROW he is EVIL. I also viewed Ashdon yesterday, he is Good.



Post #42 (SAME DAY)

Morning villagers

A mixed night last night. But fortune today as I viewed Steve Leo Beleck and he is evil!

Ashdon was viewed as good by me yesterday. Shame that the wolf jumped at that knowledge.

I do not know if Diamond is good or bad as I did not view them.


So I've proven you wrong, when you clearly lied about the messages being the wrong day.

I'm changing my vote.

 

If msg 2 is the wolf, why would the seer view Daft Row as evil when he wasn't?

That's the part you don't seem to get.

 

BECAUSE HE WAS THE TINKERRRRRRRRR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Lok who Opti voted for on day 2. DR. If Opti was the Seer, then he would have voted for the person he saw a evil!!!!

 

I need to vote by 7 at the latest if not earlier. Will back in an hour and see how things are then.

 

I'm happy to go with steve harrow tonight. I suggested him yesterday and Dom is good so I know he isn't leading the voting for evil.

And if I'm killed off tonight then please go for hornetgags as possibly the traitor tomorrow.

 

I seriously don't have a clue

Of the 5 possibilities ( based that i'm not voting for myself ) it could be anyone
Powerjugs
Otter
Meh!
Hornetsgags
Steve Harrow
(WaS)

 

Very unsure of who to vote for tonight.

Message 2 today - either the Wolf slipped up and used "Bingo!" or the back up Seer accidentally did it. First seems more likely on the balance of probabilities so not happy that NW Orn is Evil.

Can follow Meh's thinking for both Steve Harrow and Hornetgags. It's speculation but so is everything at the moment, can't decide which way to go!

 

I think I trust you WAS. Your voting on day 1 was not the voting of a wolf I think. Too exposed with Mike. I may be wrong.

 

Off to pick the nipper from football and take him to the pub .

Will try and check in and see who vote is going as Im still undecided, it s gonna have to be a hunch vote.

 

Yeah mine is only a hunch. But hornetgags has suddenly got very animated and hot under the collar about SLB after being pretty quiet all game.

 

@Otter this has been bugging me all afternoon

All day you have been saying that NW and I are on the same side, one Alpha the other beta or traitor.

Then there is a sudden turn around after the 2nd message, when you pointed the finger at me thinking that I could be naming NW to divert your finger pointing away from myself.

That is a big big swing from yourself. Having pushed you all day to why you kept thinking that NW was evil, a question you never answered, to all of a sudden NW being innocent ??

Why the change of heart ?

 

I will bring this up again. Don't fall into the "and bingo" hole! It's either NW or BRLR we've got to vote for today!

 

I understand NW s he was named as evil, although we all think that this could be the wolf

By why BRLR ?

And if the consensus is BingoGate is the wolf, then why should we vote for NW ?

 

You've got to vote for someone who's named. If you vote BLRL and he's Good then we know that was from our Seer, if we vote NW Orn and he does turn out be to evil then we know that's our seer. More to gain from lynching someone named in a message rather than picking on anything else. It'd be crazy for two people to be named in messages and we don't lynch either one of them.

 

If we vote brlr and he's good it could also be the wolf.

 

Then we know NW Orn is Evil and that was our Seer.

 

You raise a good point. Although both may be good and we are no further. All we do is establish which message was which and we are down another 3 players.

 

I noticed.