Day 5

Oh dear, here we go . I was wondering when Id be witch hunted.

Its not 100%, but very likely the second message was Wolf meaning Im GOOD and NW Orn unlikely to be EVIL. Lets hedge our bets rather than witch hunting.
If you vote for me you ll be taking down a good, leaving 5-3 tomorrow which is pretty much game over .

Am leaving now, fully expecting to be rounded upon by the time I get back.

 

I'm not witch hunting you. Quite the opposite.

 

Oh sorry, I was skim reading whilst walking and totally got wrong end of the stick. I take it all that back.

 

I'm wary of choosing either person named today as just don't have confidence in the messages.

More inclined to look elsewhere.

 

My change of heart was simple, NW Orn posted this earlier (post #55), my accusation post was earlier...

If NW Orn was evil he would know either one or both of the others and so therefore he wouldn't mention you.

I will add a correction, you and NW Orn could be on the same side if you were both good.

 

If we vote BRLR:

a) Message was from Wolf and he's trying to clear an evil BLRL
b) Message was from Wolf and he's hoping we believe option A and kill a Good player in BLRL
c) Message was from Seer and BLRL is genuinely good

If we vote NW Orn:

a) Message was from Wolf playing a double bluff making it so obvious the message was from the Wolf that we don't kill NW
b) Message was from Wolf and NW Orn is Good
c) Message was from Seer and NW Orn is Evil

Have I covered all possible outcomes?

 

If you turn out not to be the harlot Steve, I'm actually going to scream out so fricking loud wherever I am, be it work, home, the shops. Basically hedging a lot on you and squibba both being good on you being it!!!

I agree about todays messages. I think harrow steve followed by gags.

I've been known to be wrong (RIP Cthulhu)

 

Because I'm bored and good is going to lose.

 

There's no clear motive to anybody else's actions and reasoning, I am the only completely confirmed Good player so can we all just trust me on this one and vote for either NW Orn or BRLR.

 

I think so but not sure how that helps! I think you have to combine the top and the bottom parts. Give me a min and I'll try

 

Ok. I will....

 

Seer viewed BRLR, he is Good. Wolf has named NW Orn as Evil so they are Good.

Seer viewed NW Orn, he is Evil. Wolf went first and named BRLR as Good. He could be either but it would be huge gamble by the Wolf. They did not know for definite there would be a Back Up Seer and so they would not be able to defend a Team Evil member if later viewed by a Back Up Seer (if there was one). Would surely make more sense to wait to see if there is a Seer?

 

@Steve Leo Beleck I don't think we are at the stage where we need to worry about protecting anyone.

As the wolves know each other and can pick off two goods tonight, it could be a good time to say who you have stayed with and out them as good

 

Ok. I'm going in. Steve harrow.

Gags, save you to defend yourself on monday.

 

I'd agree with this. With the post I made earlier we're in agreement with 2, maybe 3 confirmed Good (Message depending) as it is. This will narrow the list further, unless those you stayed with are dead.

 

Agreed. Just holding off my vote til slb replies.

 

Haha. Maybe you should have waited before posting but now you're trying to justify your early vote to sway folk?

And perhaps the wolf mentions someone else because it looks suspicious on me or just imagine it's actually the seer! Imagine that!

 

@Squibba - which out of the two named today are you going to vote for?

 

@Steve Leo Beleck Squibba voted NW Orn.

Dom voted Steve Harrow

No-one else has voted.

 

Need to know something - if Guardian protects Seer and wolf chooses Guardian what happens?

Do they get killed outside the Seer's house but still save them or does the Wolf kill the Guardian before they can protect Seer thus leaving them exposed?

 

If the Wolf chooses the Guardian, the Guardian is killed but not who he protects.

So if the Guardian is chosen while he protects me, I'd live but the Guardian would die.

No idea if the Guardian and me are both chosen though. Probably SoL and die.

 

Vote for me if you genuinely think I'm evil obviously but I would just remind you that I've not been mentioned in any of the 10 messages so far. Five messages from the seer and he or she hasn't thought me suspicious enough. If you prefer blind faith rather than logic, go for it. I mean, it's worked out marvellously so far right...?

 

How is that possible if the guardian is out protecting? Won't it be the same scenario if the wolf chooses the harlot, they won't be there?

 

And going for those who have been mentioned is going equally well isn't it DR and GrrWood!

 

No. The harlot sleeps around so cannot be found. The guardian is out in plain sight and is killed while protecting. Not sure if the person they protect is still safe though.

 

Oh man, I don't know what to suggest. Am at home alone with a grouchy 3 year old who needs dinner, bath then bed so will have to make a snap decision close to end of voting.

At the moment, I leaning towards following Squibba and voting NW Orn and just hoping the Wolf messed up.

 

Do it. I'm 100% good, I could be wrong but at least you can't doubt my intentions.

 

That's exactly what I said earlier. Why would the wolf post 1st. The 2nd message is the wolf and as SLB says the intention is to divert away from someone under suspicion. At that time that was Meh and WAS .

That's where we need to be looking.

 

Where do you suggest we look ?

 

Why not tell us who you've already slept with?

 

I follow the logic of eliminating the options . That tactic would have been brilliant a day or two ago, when we had the time to follow it through to its natural conclusion but in all liklihood its going to end up killing a GOOD tonight. We don t have the time. Where were you 2 days ago Squibba , we could have done with you then.

We absolutely need to nail an EVIL tonight otherwise we pretty much lose

 

To be honest, this must be my 4th/5th game now and I'm only now starting to feel confident in my hunches. I feel experienced now and I am starting to see patterns of behaviour in this game from other games etc so that's why I'm putting my neck on the line!

 

I'm trying to imagine a reason or bloody new made up rule/role by harrow why an actual harlot may have stayed quiet throughout the game and SLB has been given a free pass throughout, or that the harlot is evil in this game. I've defended SLB all the way but would be just like Harrow to alter the game!!!

 

All bar one are dead.

If I give that info over, then Evil will not try to fit that one person up to deflect from one of their own.

 

If SLB is Evil then it's the single most brilliantly blinding game of Werewolf ever played!