DAY 3 - Werewolf 2018

How would I know the clue? Im not the seer.

Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

 

Indeed. I think Harrow has been playing a classic Alpha game. Fairly low profile, posts just enough, throws around some doubt and mayhem and votes in a way which means he doesn't risk harming his team mates, whom he wouldn't know the identities of.

Also the kills look like obvious set ups, as each kill was someone who had had a spat with another player the day before. See the pattern of the Wolf message and Harrow both referring to feuds as motivations for the kills of Cthulhu and SLB. Just in case we missed his motives, he has been happy to point it out to us.

 

No, but you're about the only person who has voiced any suspicion of me and then, low and behold, a message appears confirming it when you are online. You've set some traps, but people aren't falling in at the moment.

 

This is absolutely what I wanted. Now we 100% catch evil in the next two days. Like I said, Moog is 100% evil and 1st message is the seer. But you guys cant know that until you vote one of us off.

I dont mind falling on my sword but quite fancied swinging it for one last time.



Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

 

And yes that was a hint.

Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

 

I agree with this

 

Come to think of it, I do agree with message 2, Harrow tried to throw dirt on me too it didn't stick and then never mentioned it again since nobody followed that theory.

Today already he's suspicious of DomTheHornet but also convinced it's Moog. Just seems a bit wishy washy.

 

If you are the tinker then all I can do is apologise.

Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

 

Hmmm, so in a previous post you made a point about a hint, preceeded by a previous post about swinging a sword - suggesting you are the Guardian
Now you are hinting that you are, in fact, the seer, even though you've only just told us that you're not the seer, which would've been fair enough.

 

I am not the seer but I know the first message is the seer. Hence that comment.

But glad someone picked up on the sword comments

Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

 

Haha yeah, it's possible you are both good. I can't change my vote, and it's getting late for me anyway, but you do seem somewhat confident in your assertations. Irrespective of that we can't vote with the mindset somebody might be the tinker.

 

Good news guaranteed an evil today or tomorrow , going by messages i am in my now customary state of confusion ,logically we have to vote for harrow or moog , anyone got a coin handy!

 

I can confirm I am the Guardian. Only thing I can do right now really. I have been liking Meh's posts when he mentions the guardian to hint it to him.

You will see its true as nobody will come forward and claim they are the guardian. If they do they are a suspect as they would be lying about their role.

 

Well, at least we'll get one member of the evil team in the next couple of days - Harrow Orn, if I remember correctly, played a very similar game last time round he played - i.e. throwing out accusation and trying to pick up a reaction or two so wouldn't look too far into the way he's playing the game.

 

I did notice!

 

Thank you

 

Whilst you may be the guardian, it would be crazy if you were lying, for the real guardian to come out considering there's at least another wolf

Personally I'm edging towards Moog at the moment

 

Well we are almost guaranteed an evil in the next 2 days.

The question I’m going to think about is why we received the second message. A wolf might have posted to throw the scent off themselves. But Harrow wouldn’t have done that about himself.

Was it just a late viewing? If so, why? Early messages always help team good.

 

We're really not actually. I fancy we may have unearthed our tinker but I'd be pleasantly surprised if we are a wolf less by tomorrow night.

 

Interesting!!

 

You know theres a guardian in the game. I have told you its me and dropped hints to meh in the past few hours which he confirms hes noticed.

Voting for me would be incredibly unwise right now

 

If it's you you will be dead by morning anyway.

 

Yup. But i can protect someone else first

 

So between Moog and Harrow Orn, we are going to nab an Evil. Whilst I like Moog's approach to the game more in terms of following messages and logic, I'm leaning towards Harrow being Good. Still mulling it over.

As others said, the 1st message definitely has a whiff of CnP about it which makes it dubious, but the timing in theory would help Good more.

Unless he guards himself... is that a thing?

 

Guardian can protect themselves though, right? He'll be dead tomorrow night though I imagine

 

Yes its in the rules for this game that guardian can choose to protect himself.

 

After last night, does the Alpha and Beta wolf know one another?

 

Meh noticing that you liked his posts proves nothing.

As previously said, the real Guardian would be insane to out themselves now as they'd effectively sign their death warrant and neutralise a valuable role for team GOOD.

Nice try to take a VERY GOOD member out of the game with you though.

 

Moog's approach to the game has led to 2 good people dying. He was dangerously leading everyone astray. Im so glad our seer has viewed him.

 

They can protect themselves once.....as roles go Guardian is pretty ineffectual unless they are exceptionally good. My claim to fame was the first Guardian to actually protect a player from attack, (complete luck btw). In a subsequent game the Guardian managed to save two players. Three villagers saved in the history of Werewolf here isn't a great return. I would say undoubtedly it's worth sacrificing the Guardian for Moog if he is a wolf....flipping ironic if we lose the Guardian for a tinker though!

 

Baseless. I voted the same way as the majority on both days, based on messages. In the first two days, it's obviously likely that good people will die. You know that as well as I do.

 

Having seen both messages I would have gone with the 1st being from the seer.
Who ever has done the 2nd message hasn't backed up the views from previous days, as the 1st message today and the seer's message yesterday

Harrow outing himself will only prove to be the greatest bluff if no-one else comes out and discredits his claim. He'll probably guard himself tonight and live to fight at least one more day

Sorry Moog, but harrow has just edged slightly ahead of you with his claim.

 

I'm utterly convinced that Harrow isn't the tinker. He's not behaving like someone who's surprised to have been named as evil. More like he's got it all mapped out with a cover story and strategy that he's seemingly been following from Day 1.

Being named as evil is clearly not ideal to him, but he can maximise damage before he goes if he 1. gets Team Good to first lynch another good player and 2. get the Guardian to out themselves, giving him or his Beta a chance to take them out of the game.

He knows he's going down, but he wants to go down in flames with some good people too.