Day 2

If its the tough guy role we ll know tomorrow as he ll die after his extra day has been used up.

If its the Amulet being used then we ll also know soon, because someone else will suspiciously survive an attack like PJ did.

If neither of these options arise in the next day or two ( and there are no other roles that PJ could be ) then we can only assume that PJ is a wolf no? Because why else would he be out of his house at night.

 

Don't discount another possibility that he could be a role not on that wiki i.e. an immune traitor, who can only be killed by lynching and not by wolf.

 

Read through previous posts BRLR. There's no way I can be Evil this game. The wolf chose to kill me. If I was a wolf he would have killed me as an Alpha werewolf can kill all lesser werewolves, even if the lesser werewolf had killed someone beforehand in the same night. I simply wasn't at my home when attacked or else I'd be dead. I cannot be a Traitor or a Tinker either as I was viewed as Good by the Seer on day one with the unhelpfully poetic message.

Going back to my house that was pretty much destroyed, WHY IS THERE A MASSIVE **** ON MY BED!? PHELPS!

 

We've still not established which message was from the Seer/Wolf. It seems likely you're good but not a certainty.

 

Fair enough.

 

Powerjugs isn't playing the game like they're on borrowed time so I doubt they're the tough guy.

 

Sorry observing Ramadan, on a weird timetable.

What's the latest? Is there 100% a new role because as far as I can remember nobodies ever "not been home" before?

 

It is a new role not seen here before AFAIK.

 

He made his vote at 13.20 GMT . Phillipines is only 8 hours ahead, so he either goes to bed very early at 9.30pm or hes lieing.

 

Any suggestions on who to vote for then? I'm going Cinema after work so will need to cast my vote around 530ish latest.

 

9:30pm is a reasonable time to log off a internet forum and go to bed isn't it?

 

Not if youre a wolf!

 

I think the wolf would stay awake to watch the game and get his emails in haha. Anyway, all trivial! I do not have the foggiest on who to vote for.

 

Ross he might be an early shift kinda guy , I have to get up at stupid o clock and get back fairly early !

For what it's worth I am struggling to make much sense of this although I think I know who the guardian is , but don't wish to put him on a plate for team evil
Squibba doubted my dead doggy ,it could be a tactic , but one I wouldn't use ,especially when the wound is still raw!
Not many posts so far Sqibba ,using Ramadan as an excuse for not posting ,
Are you a wolf ?

 

Im not sure if Im breaking convention but its unlikely that a complete noob, like myself, would be given an important role and so in my defence I would say that logic implies that Im not the wolf.

The only reason I feel the need to defend myself is because I already have 1 vote against me and Im concerned that it may accrete momentum .

As others have said there is very little to go on, apart from POs eagerness to target me so readily , which may or may not be a smokescreen, but with so little else to go on Im going to vote for PhillipineOrn.

Im have to go out now which is why Im making my vote early.

 

Ok some think the poetic message is the seer ,but what if it's the wolf ,what does that do to the logic of those named on day 1 and how would that affect those named on day 2 ?
Basically thinking aloud here , unlikely as others have said but not totally disproved.

 

Ross newbies can get starring roles mate ,it's usually sorted by a random generator ,unless Harrow has done things differently.

 

I'll be honest there is no real candidate to vote for.

A few have been relatively quiet, there are some questions about PJ's new role and lets face it none of us really know who each message is from as yet.

There are a few likes and supportive messages, which could be the masons trying to influence the vote but that's about all.

At the moment I am going to vote for someone who has tried to influence who we vote for, both yesterday and again today, using the same reasoning, that we should vote for the quieter players as they are more likely to be evil.

Other than them trying to influence who to vote for i have nothing to go on.

 

Nothing can be fully proven or disproven until the late game most likely. We can speculate and try to follow logic that stays in line with Werewolf rules but that's all we can do so early in the game.

 

How about we all give each other 1 vote and make HarrowOrns job difficult?

 

Random generator I found online.

Not fair to pick roles out for specific people!

 

Honestly, I thought it was hand picked! TIL

 

Right,

I knew someone in an old game used to come into the Tavern and write poems.

Just had a look at the 2015 game run by 352 and it was Meh who wasn't actually in that game he just liked to join in the tavern however he is playing this year.

Whether that first message was from the Seer or the Wolf I don't know but I'm going to risk my own life and stick my neck out and say Meh is the player who wrote the first message yesterday.

 

Ok I'm just going to say what everyone else is thinking...

PJ is a wolf and the reason he wasn't home was because he was out splicing and a dicing...maybe...possibly...I, for one, welcome our new werewolf overlords.

 

Risky move outing a wolf or the seer ,if it's the wolf his buddy will target you unless you are the other wolf, or outing the seer , I do applaud your diligence though.

 

Thats an interesting idea but I can't imagine Harrow / Opti being so obvious in their write-up?

 

PJ replied to my post suggesting he couldnt possibly be the wolf by vehemently arguing that there was no logical way he could be, because if was he, would have been killed by the Alpha wolf.

But he wouldnt have been killed if he was out killing himself no ?

 

As written before, I would be dead as a Wolf targeted me. If I was a Beta wolf I'd be dead right now. Read the rules. Any experienced player will attest to this. The fun of a new role.

Don't accuse others without being able to justify why, else you can potentially aid Evil in their fight and you'll portray yourself in a bad light.

 

What PJ said, if Alpha attacks Beta then Beta dies, if Beta attack Alpha, Beta dies.

 

Can someone explain to me why PJ categorically can not be the alpha wolf my head is starting to hurt !