Summer Werewolf 2023 - Day Two

1 seer, 10 villagers, 3 wolves and a traitor.

Tom and I are confirmed good (unless you believe the Tinker theory).

So 4 evils amongst the 9 remaining players. Just under a 50% chance of hitting a baddy for the lynching.

Suggest we start naming a shortlist for the chop and see who starts trying to save who when names are in the frame.

Opti - barely posting and has just commented bland stuff
TonyCoton - commenting lots but mainly jokey responses to stuff
HH24 - very involved, correcting false assumptions
Ctulhu - very involved, also correcting things
Norway - reasonably involved, one post pointing at the rules about there being no Tinker but in a "sit on the fence" type way
Harrow Orn - reasonably involved, offering opinions
Moog - very involved, some theories and trying to move game along
Cassetti's Beard - reasonably involved but very interested in the code getting cracked
WfcWarehouse - reasonably involved but not really offering opinions, only agreed with one thing someone else said
Sinatra - forgot to play yesterday, one nothing comment today
Skyla - very involved, theories galore
Garbelia - one post yesterday just to say that had posted
Steve Harrow - no posts, seems to have forgotten to play

There will be at least one wolf hiding in the "reasonably involved, not saying much of note" camp which is TonyCoton, Norway, Cassetti's Beard and WfcWarehouse.

That's my shortlist for the noose tonight.

 

I still think Garbelia is a wolf, but happy to settle on one of your four named. CB or TCT for me based on nothing more than a hunch.

 

Looks like three players didn't vote yesterday, Sinatra and Steve obviously two of them. Shame we can't see who the third was - anyone want to own up?

 

@domthehornet do you know the answer?

 

SLB is trying to lead the vote here. It may be just a genuine attempt to move the game forwards as it's been pretty plodding so far, but worth remembering in the future if those on his shortlist, such as myself, turn out to be innocent - which I've already said earlier I am.

For me, the codes in the messages mean nothing unless there's someone out there who is much cleverer than me who has it sussed. I really can't make my mind up on which message is the Seer, which is the Wolf.

Personally, I would've liked to have been more involved but my working week is panning out to be much busier than I anticipcated so apologies for that. I'm going to have some time after I finish today to re-read yesterday and todays threads.

 

OK, let's all go for warehouse, based on that.

 

Think we can rule out Steve Harrow as it seems all three wolves are active (two tried to kill otter and another killed Miked)

 

If they truly are inactive, then there's a very good chance they aren't evil as all three wolves were active during last nights killing - obviously there's a chance it's a bluff and they may pop in before 6 to post a message to avoid being killed by Dom for being inactive. For tonight I think we should avoid killing wfcsinatra, steve harrow and Garbelia as they will all be killed off anyway if they don't post.

 

I'm voting for whoever has posted a lot without actually saying anything in the process.

Someone appearing to be busy, but scared to ruffle any feathers.

 

That would be too obvious though surely?

 

Sorry didn't appreciate game started yesterday. Not read anything at all to be honest but will catch up as quick as I can!

Yes I'm an eejit.

Sent from my Pixel 3a XL using Tapatalk

 

A traitor-like response if ever I saw one... Couple of your friends on the shortlist?

 

Be my guest - it's a wasted vote.

 

the Pixel 3a XL has an especially sensitive touchscreen, suitable for claws and paws. Make of that what you will.

 

that's exactly what a Wolf would say.

 

I also don't like this post. It scares me how eager Moog is to vote for... Well... anybody.

 

So is that, if I apply your logic?

 

So for my two pennies worth I’m not sure what to make of the messages thus far. It seems a stretch for the seer to have found a tinker yesterday, but that has to happen at some point in all these games of werewolf.

I really don’t know who to vote for. It feels imperative that we get an evil player today, but we have nothing to go on. My gut would be to vote for a less active player, I realise that might include myself but I have been working both days so far.

It’s busy time for my equine department.

 

So what has changed? I'm assuming it's you who has voted for me - does that not also mean you're suspicious?

 

I stand corrected, it was Moog.

 

Moog's rash judgement to vote for me is strange, but I don't think he's wolf - he's a very experienced player who is very active in his gameplay, so I don't blame him for trying to get things moving.

Having looked back through, I think Cassetti's Beards behaviour is a little erratic. They were very quick to state their certainty that message one today was the seer. They also seem to be fixated on cracking the codes within the messages which I don't think is a worthwhile use of time. I'm happy to be corrected once the game is over but I can't see any sensible translation to them, so I think they're just there to muddy waters for whatever reason.

I think CB is my pick at the moment, unless I go for a random inactive player which would be a waste given Dom's clarification earlier.

 

I am honestly just more impulsive when there's nothing to go on.

I guess and pull the trigger. Everyone else guesses, second guesses, triple guesses and are still none the wiser. I'm just taking a shortcut.

 

it's the nature of the game, is it not?

The only firm insight we get each day is from the two messages, both of which we've had for some time. Other than that, forensic examination of everyone's pattern of play from the past 2 days is very little to go on. Thin gruel indeed.

Warehouse seemed to try and accuse SLB, who is confirmed as good in my eyes, along with Tom. Plus he played very quietly until accused and suddenly stepped up. Is it a smoking gun? No. Will we find such evidence between now and 1800? unlikely. Am I likely to be distracted between now and then and forget to vote? That is entirely possi