Summer Werewolf 2023 - Day Three

Yep that's the error I spotted.

 

A few comments in here from me in bold. And then onto you Mr Cthuhlhu - I actually don't know what to think. I'd probably say you're very middle of the road too.

 

HH didn't vote for WfcWarehouse, she voted for Opti.

So your four Evils are Norway, HH24, Tony and Moog?

 

What's the error? Prepared to say which messages you think are good and which are evil?

 

Ah yeah. She said:

"It’s basically “toss a coin” time for me between warehouse and Opti, but going for Opti on the basis that he’s fooled me before and I don’t understand why he is claiming to be confused by the messages."

Then:

"To be honest, I don’t have strong feelings that either Opti or Warehouse are wolves - the behaviour from a previous game, however, is Opti using the “busy at work” line when he was inactive and he turned out to be a wolf, so is relevant to today. That said, do I strongly think he’s a wolf? No, but neither do I strongly think warehouse is a wolf and he has contributed more."

My suspicions still stand. Removing herself from any blame if whoever she votes for is team good. And then, still voting opti even though she didn't think he was a wolf. It is so suspicious.

 

I.e. if you dont think someone is evil dont vote for them.

And yes, those four are my suspicions.

 

It just seemed like a conscious effort from you to almost apologise for your vote straight away, as if you were covering your tracks.

Skyla had been a lot more vocal than you, I think she was being quite proactive in trying to figure out the game which goes in her favour.

I can be top of your list, I don't mind. It seems like the main reason I am is because I'm putting you under pressure. It's an interesting reaction.

 

I'm voting early. @GarbeliaHornet for me should be voted or seen asap. Too much sudden energy after a couple of quiet days.

Moog has to be lynched to get some clarity between messages.

I appear to be wrong about SLB based on doing a Skyla and mixing up the messages.

 

I don't think someone being confused about the game set up is indicative of the team they're on.

 

Lol wolfy some of us have life to deal with today has been manic end of an aircraft servicing always is .
People want a top 3 I'm going SLB Cthulu and Moog no reason or thinking yet as haven't had time to catch up last few hours
We know its usual for wolves to stay in background, I'm thinking that folk steering the conversion might be the wolves ,it would be a clever new tactic.

 

My top 3 if we're doing it:

1. Moog - obvious choice today given the messages and who we think is the seer (assuming no tinker, bugger it if there is one after all). Moog being moog has already voted for themselves.
2. Harrow Orn
3. Tonycotonstace

 

Picking SLB means you think the post naming them as good is from the wolf. Which means you think Ashdon is the tinker which in turn suggests you think Moog was named today by a wolf. Yet he's also in your top 3. Are you bad or mad?

 

I also mentioned there was no logic or thinking behind that ,Cthulu and SLB wanted names I gave names , I'm still trying to catch up .

 

Who were yours? You had quite a long post setting out some thoughts but who you would you pick at this stage?

 

Why?

Why?

 

So shocked I reacted to it twice.

 

Purely an availability thing.

 

It wouldn't be first time I've been called mad.
To answer your question directly.

 

Three hours to go and the following are not playing ball with naming their top three suspects:

HH24, Cassetti's Beard, Moog, Sinatra, Opti.

If the ones on that list that are Team Good could hurry up and do it, would be helpful to the village as some patterns are already emerging. Don't worry if you're uncertain, none of us on Team Good know for definite... yet!

 

It's a shame people are suspecting me but paying the price for actively posting I feel.

I won't let it change my approach either way. The more conversations the better.

 

At this point everyone has to come under some scrutiny.

 

SLB
TCT

based on evidence, I would say Me, Moog and WFCMoog are the most under suspicion.

 

Posting to name 3 players who you think are experienced and suspicious - like playing previously has anything to do with the role they have now. Suggests you want those folk gone for your own nefarious reasons. Then 2 days later claimed it was a joke. And just a few other comments I felt tried to lead people astray.

In your defence, you voted for Moog today earlier than me.

Nothing personal Harrow, clearly we (anyone good) are all guessing to some degree or other.

 

Why only two?

 

Moog is obviously choice number 1.

It's then two of the following IMO:

Opti
Tony
Happy
Cthulhu
Harrow

 

At the end of that post I said

"GG. Who shall we vote first?"

It was clearly a joke pretending I'd nailed the three wolves and we could end the game quickly. I'm surprised people have taken it so seriously.

And are you sure it's not personal? You clearly think there's only room for one Steve from Harrow allowed in this game. Disgraceful!

 

It is worth considering that if moog is evil, then we can discount one set of messages as being from the alpha. That set of messages proclaimed Tony to be good right after it was suggested that the wolves discovered each other. Might be worth considering, although it may be a bit too obvious.

 

Actually HH24 had Harrow, Opti, Moog and Sinatra listed in a post so will add her to the list of people prepared to lay their cards on the table. Only Sinatra who hasn't (but let's be honest, that's hardly surprising!).

Edit: and Opti