F1/ Formula E/ Motorsport Thread

Discussion in 'General Football & Other Sport' started by hornmeister, Nov 14, 2010.

  1. UEA_Hornet

    UEA_Hornet First Team Captain

    To be fair molly I pretty much have. I've not bothered with any of the last 6 races but no doubt I'll tune in again in March and see how the latest regulation changes pan out.
     
  2. molly

    molly Reservist

    But what has really changed this season? The gulf between the winning team and the rest might have been larger but it's only a question of scale - a single team dominates pretty much every season. Does it really matter by if that domination is greater this season than previous ones? I believe the real reason people don't like the Red Bull team is because they're spanking the traditional favourites like Ferrari. I guess it would be a bit like if a newly formed football team with no history (MK Dons?) won the premier league year in, year out by a thirty point margin. All the Man U, Arsenal and Chelsea fans would get pi$$ed off very quickly.
     
  3. nornironhorn

    nornironhorn Administrator Staff Member

    I think its just because recently we have had a couple of seasons go right down to the wire, whereas this season was wrapped up long before the end.

    You could always tell if Vettel was leading after 1 or 2 laps he was going to win, just takes away a little excitement in my eyes
     
  4. wfc4ever

    wfc4ever Administrator Staff Member

    Behind Vettel its not been too bad with various teams/drivers have a good/bad spell but of course they are all racing for 2nd...
     
  5. fan

    fan slow toaster

    i've never been a fan of formula 1, and this race did nothing to change my opinion. person starts a race in first position, finishes the race in first position, thrilling shizzle! the crowd was surprisingly misogynistic too. every time a woman walked across the front of the grand stand, people would shout out crudest things. this has never happened at any of the football matches i go to, so i was curious as to whether this is a f1 phenomenon?

    i do have to give them credit for the after party though. i managed to fluke free entry to both the club and the vip section (with all the free champagne and gin you can handle) and it was comfortably one of the best parties i have ever graced. i even got interviewed by vice tv while i was in my stupor and had a chat with a driver.
     
  6. 2007, 2008, 2010 were all great seasons that went down to the wire, especially 2010 when 5 drivers all had a realistic chance with 2 races to go.

    2013? yawn
     
  7. hornmeister

    hornmeister Tired

    Completely lost interest this year, even with Sky's excellent coverage.

    They should start races in the reverse finishing order of the last race.
     
  8. Reverse grids would be brilliant, every race would be worth watching even with all conquering Newey-mobiles dominating

    I'd like to see 1/2 the points for qualy, then reverse the grid in qualy order, then 1/2 the points for the race
     
  9. scummybear

    scummybear Reservist

    Those saying the cars should all be the same and it should be all down to the drivers seem to be missing a major point, F1 is a team sport! It'd be like saying that all football teams should be made to play the same formation, tactics, and identical training facilities!

    There are plenty of racing series where they race in identical cars, although they are usually only National. Or alternatively follow Touring Cars, where they actually add balast to the winning driver's car to even the pack out! I think it might even be BTCC where they draw lots for the top 10 on the grid?
     
  10. UEA_Hornet

    UEA_Hornet First Team Captain

    Some might argue that F1 is a one man sport. And that man ain't Vettel.
     
  11. Timbers

    Timbers Apeman

    One of the things Brundle was saying on Sunday was about getting rid of practice on the Fridays. Have Friday as qualifying and then a 'sprint' race on Saturday lasting for an hour and a 'feature' race on the Sunday. This would be a like the GP2 and GP3 series. It would allow less set up times and teams would have to balance how much they put into the lesser Saturday race for the big guns.
     
  12. Smudger

    Smudger Messi's Mad Coach Staff Member

    The difference between teams in terms of their financial muscle would be a start to evening up the grid. And also lower the barriers to new start up teams. You used to get throughout the history of F1 alongside the works teams, privateers and new teams but the sheer budgets required now actively threaten to reduce the number of teams year on year. How long before Marussia and Caterham even Sauber give up the ghost ?

    It is in a way analagous to the situation in many sports where a few teams have all the power to the detriment of the sport. The FIA have had to use convoluted rules, DRS, tyres to make racing more competitive as they were well aware many fans were getting turned off by the constant stream of processionals.
     
  13. molly

    molly Reservist

    As you say, it's the same as in other sports - take football for example. It would be a ludicrous idea to give all the teams in all the leagues the same amount of money to play with in order to even things up and make football more interesting. So why would it be any less ludicrous in F1 ?
    It seems to me that the fans want their cake and to eat it. On the one hand they want to see the cars get faster and mechanically more ingenious, with a driver who has the necessary skills to control such a monster of a machine - but on the other they complain when a team makes technological breakthroughs and employs a phenomenal driver, as this makes the spectacle somehow less interesting.
     
  14. Norwayhornet

    Norwayhornet Squad Player

    Was never a fan of F1 but this season for me has plumbed new lows as a spectator sport its as exciting as watching paint dry . with loads of races to go we all knew who had won it , only good thing about it was betting on Vettel was easy money.
    Now the GP WSB and BSB far more fun :)
     
  15. F1 and football are a silly analogy, they are nothing alike. In football we don't have to watch Barcelona smash Watford 10-0 every single week 46 games a season.

    My guess is you're either a Vetel fan or work for Red Bull. I can appreciate the engineering excellence of Red Bull, but its boring and it's turning people off.

    I was an F1 nut in years past and have been to GP's all over the world. But if you gave me a ticket now I'd probably ebay it.... and use the money to buy a DTM ticket instead.
     
  16. Smudger

    Smudger Messi's Mad Coach Staff Member

    I'm not too sure about that Molly. I can see where you are coming from in one way. F1 is the white heat of technology at the edge and certain manufacturers do use that to better their road cars or use it as a promotional element in their marketing. But deep down in all sports people are looking for a human element and there are fears that the technology has become too preeminent over the human component of the driver.

    You can say that it has been this way for a long time with driver aids for example. But it is turning people off and if any sport does become predictable then people will turn off. Viewing figures for events where the outcome can be predicted to a reasonable accuracy are lower for a reason. People like to see the unexpected unwritten drama every once in a while in their chosen sports that they watch.

    At present certainly after the change Pirelli made with their tyres it has become more of a question of who will finish second after the first few corners such is the mechanical reliability of the modern F1 car. And if this keeps repeating itself people will get bored. I wonder why for example Marussia or Caterham even bother sometimes. This is in no way a slight on Vettel of Red Bull or Newey. They should be admired for what they have acheived and Seb is an excellent driver but the spectacle is missing partly because in a way Webber has not been up to the challenge when certain manufacturers dominated both number 1 and 2 at least duelled it out for the World title.

    Some drivers would even like a reduction in technology and when they talk about F1 of the past the admiration they have for their forbears is visible in their faces and voices.
     
  17. Smudger

    Smudger Messi's Mad Coach Staff Member

    Nico Hulkenberg has joined Force India again which means either Sutil or di Resta will have to find out who is leaving.

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/formula1/25205390

    Race schedule for 2014 has been released:
    16 March Australia (Melbourne)
    30 March Malaysia (Sepang)
    6 April Bahrain (Sakhir)
    20 April China (Shanghai)
    11 May Spain (Barcelona)
    25 May Monaco (Monte Carlo)
    8 June Canada (Montreal)
    22 June Austria (Red Bull Ring)
    6 July Britain (Silverstone)
    20 July Germany (Hockenheim)
    27 July Hungary (Budapest)
    24 August Belgium (Spa-Francorchamps)
    7 September Italy (Monza)
    21 September Singapore (Marina Bay)
    5 October Japan (Suzuka)
    12 October Russia (Sochi)
    2 November USA (Austin)
    9 November Brazil (Sao Paulo)
    23 November Abu Dhabi (Yas Marina)

    The Manhattan GP has been put on hold, the dull Korean and Mexican GP's have been abandoned. There is a new venue in Sochi to tie in with that town's hosting of the Winter Olympiad in February and the Austrian GP is back at the old Osterreichring which is reasonable given the success of Austrian drivers in the sport. Red Bull have overhauled the circuit and the pit complex. Wonder if the other teams will feel disgruntled as no doubt they will have more data for their drivers when the race takes place.

    The Bahrain GP will be a night time affair partly for spectacle and partly for audience ratings.
     
    Last edited: Dec 4, 2013
  18. Smudger

    Smudger Messi's Mad Coach Staff Member

    As the year draws to it's inevitable close I think it might be nice to remember those who have passed away this year while competing in the world of motorsport. Despite the advances in safety measures, track design and medical procedures it remains a sport which claims lives.


    Thomas Bourgin Age 26

    [​IMG]

    11th January. Died in the Dakar rally in Chile following a head on collision with a police support vehicle.

    Christian Devereux Age 51

    [​IMG]

    5th May. Died after a car collision at the Donnington Historic Festival at Donnington Park.

    **** Trickle Age 72

    [​IMG]

    May 16th. A legend in NASCAR he committed suicide. He had lost his granddaughter in an accident which may have been a contributory factor.

    Yoshinari Matsush ita Age 44

    [​IMG]

    27th May. Died after an accident in a practice run in the Isle of Man TT at Ballacrye. He came off his bike in wet conditions after a tankslapper and hit a roadside sign.

    Mark Robinson Age 38

    [​IMG]

    9th June. Track marshall who died at the Canadian F1 GP. While retrieving the Sauber car of Esteban Gutierrez he was run over by the rescue crane.

    Jason Leffler Age 38

    [​IMG]

    12th June. Died at the Bridgeport Speedway in NJ during a test run. He was a former NASCAR racer who had returned to sprint racing which uses open wheel cockpits on dirt tracks. A suspension failure led to a collision with a wall and blunt trauma to the neck.

    Wolf Silvester Age 55

    [​IMG]

    22nd June. Died at the Nurburgring during a VLN Endurance Racing Championship of a heart attack. The stress of driving at high speed around this still notoriously difficult circuit is presumed to have precipitated the cardiac arrest.

    Allan Simonsen Age 35

    [​IMG]

    22nd June. Died at the 24 Hours of Le Mans Car after his car slid off the track and hit the armco barrier. At that precise point there was a tree behind the armco. Therefore all the energy of impact transferred into the car. Although talking after the crash he slipped into a coma and the deceleration injury is thought to have caused a ruptured aorta and brain damage.

    Andrea Antonelli Age 25

    [​IMG]

    21st July. He was competing at the Moscow Raceway in a World Supersport race in wet conditions. He lost control of his bike and in an incident that mirrored the death of his compatriot Marco Simoncelli was hit in the head at 250 kph by another racer.

    Maria de Villota Age 33

    [​IMG]

    11th October. Maria suffered a horrific crash while testing for Marussia F1 last year a year to the day she died. She thankfully recovered despite losing an eye but the severity of the cranial injuries for which was still due to receive operations are thought to have precipitated a heart attack. She died in Sevilla just months after being married and becoming an inspirational speaker to others who have survived traumatic injuries.

    Sean Edwards Age 27

    [​IMG]

    15th October. Died in an accident at Queensland Raceway after the cars throttle jammed resulting in a high speed collision with a wall.At the time he was leading the World Porsche Supercup standings. He like Maria was the child of a former F1 race driver.

    God bless them all.
     
  19. Smudger

    Smudger Messi's Mad Coach Staff Member

  20. PowerJugs

    PowerJugs Doyley Fanatic

    Sounds like they made F1 cars sh***er
     
  21. UEA_Hornet

    UEA_Hornet First Team Captain

    They've now added on double points for the last race and drivers being able to choose car numbers which stay with them throughout their career.
     
  22. Davidwfc

    Davidwfc Reservist

    I thought you were joking when you posted that., but now I see its true. I dont agree with double points for the last race. They should not make changes that mock the history of former champions. If double points were in effect for all of F1 seasons then the list of world champions would be very different. Hamilton would not be a world champion for one. I also dont see the need to change the numbers system.
     
  23. hornmeister

    hornmeister Tired

    It's all tinkering. F1 should be pretty restriction free. It's the pinnacle of the sport and where a lot of technology is invented. They should keep reducing the max size of the engine to keep speeds sensible but I think pretty much anything else should be allowed.

    Making people use 2 different tyre compounds in a race is silly. Having DRS zones is stupid. Let people have variable pitch aerodynamics, mulitple turbochargers tyres or any manufacture and quantity in a race, permit ground effect, just limit the engine size to 1.4L.
     
  24. scummybear

    scummybear Reservist

    What the hell are they thinking with this double points thing?! F1 is losing its philosophy of real racing and just turning into a gimmick!

    The driver numbers makes sense though, pretty much every other form of motorsport uses driver/rider numbers. You can't think of Rossi without the number 46!

    Time to shift to IndyCar, I think. Especially if Di Resta gets a drive at Ganassi!
     
  25. nornironhorn

    nornironhorn Administrator Staff Member

    Kobayashi is back, great news
     
  26. hornmeister

    hornmeister Tired

    KobiCrashi should liven it up a bit.
     
  27. nornironhorn

    nornironhorn Administrator Staff Member

    Pity he is in a crap car, really want him to do a race in a red bull or something just to see how he would do (obviously never going to happen)

    I reckon if him and Vettel were in the same car he would beat him if he didn't crash, although the risk of crashing is massive.
     
  28. PowerJugs

    PowerJugs Doyley Fanatic

    See bold
     
  29. Optimistichornet

    Optimistichornet Penguin Assassin

    kobiyashi is my favourite driver, very entertaining. my dream team would contain him and Hamilton racing together.
     
  30. nornironhorn

    nornironhorn Administrator Staff Member

    Kobayashi and Maldonado would be my dream team
     
  31. Timbers

    Timbers Apeman

    Expensive repair bills though!
     
  32. 1-0 to Mercedes then, as Renault make a total Nani of their engine
     
  33. Smudger

    Smudger Messi's Mad Coach Staff Member

  34. nisman94

    nisman94 International Man of Mystery

    Like I said somewhere else in this thread, I got into F1 when I was young in the time of Schumacher, Hakkinen etc. and it was was an exciting sport then, where it focused on how good the drivers were. Now it's just which team has the better technology. Whilst I like the fact that this shows the technological advances that have taken place in motor sport, it's massively detracted from the point of the competition in the first place and it's lost its charm for me
     
  35. lm_wfc

    lm_wfc First Team

    Technology has always been part of it, back when Schumacher dominated Ferrar were fast, barichello (sp) was normally 2nd in the championship.

    Maybe I'm biased but I think it should be about the cars too. Yes it's borign when one team dominates, but's boring when one driver dominates too. F1 is about the engineering and fastest cars.
     

Share This Page