Day 4

I don't think we'll get a second message.

 

My first thoughts were the opposite i.e. it was received at 3/4 am, and therefore PO was the first person I thought of.

 

Daft Row. When you said that you "don't want to ruin the surprise" yesterday, what did you mean?

 

Ffs. What an awful night. Guess the wolf gave up on Powerjugs too now!

One thing we need to consider is that Cthulthu could have been the tinker as they still would have been declared good.

The original seer is the only one that could have confirmed that. Daft Row may still ens up being good. We don't have any choice though really.

 

I was sure Cthulhu was evil as I knew my own innocence... thought good were on the right track. I wouldn't have said that last night if I was the wolf and then needed to defend myself today.

 

You may well have hung yourself with that comment.

 

Ah... second message could still be from the seer and I'm not necessarily the tinker?

 

Why?

 

Anonymous Message 2:

 

Hmmm that's a little obvious and not unexpected

 

Maybe time to analyse who hadn't posted much again , this might take a while

 

How so? Currently you are looking a guilty as a puppy sitting next to a pile of poo.

Looking at the messages, I assume a good tactic from the new seer by choosing to look at someone who's not been in the discussion much but as Norway said a pretty obvious wolf message to follow in the hope of creating the same tug-of-war we saw yesterday; however it won't work as most people will be looking at Daft Row today.

 

My opinion hasn't changed re: voting for Daft Row. That was the most obvious Wolf method of trying to confuse Good. We can establish a potentially better pattern tomorrow (If game isn't paused over weekend) but let's stick to the most obvious candidate today. Daft Row is either a Tinker, Traitor or Wolf. Nothing to lose here.

My vote today is for Daft Row. Normally I'd wait around for a more complete picture but we're starting from Day 1 today again, trying to figure out who's the actual Seer and that only gets going after a day or two. We can try and figure PO after today.

 

Touché. Hadn't thought of that.

 

Unless Cthulthu was the Tinker.

But you're right. There isn't reall a choice today.

 

Because...

• If seer is first message from yesterday and finds me guilty... I am tinker
• If seer is second message from yesterday... Cthulhu could have been the tinker and I wasn't viewed

 

Daft row has realised hte mistake he made about there not being a 2nd message, has panicked and put PO into the equation to try to take the pressure off himself

Daft Row today... now need to look at who was defending him yesterday and who voted for Cthuluhulh yesterday

 

Maybe. But we're going to lose potentially 3 Good (Lynch, 2 Eaten) today if everything goes against Good. Eliminating a potential Evil would a huge step forward and we have nothing else to go on today.

 

To everyone, what's the consensus, play on over the weekend or take a break?

 

Poll! Poll! Poll! Poll!

 

On balance, the second message seems fairly wolf like, and I'm willing to completely dismiss it unless DR is found good tonight.

DR has got to go.

 

What mistake?... FFS if you're good all you are is creating conjecture.

 

Im fed up of polls.

 

Daft Row, you were so calm about being Lynched yesterday when you had Cthulhu going 50/50 with you. You welcomed being bumped off for the greater good. Now you're a more panicky compared to a very calm display yesterday now there's no-one else. I thought you'd be welcoming this as per yesterday.

What gives?

 

Racist.

 

Err

Then all of a sudden a 2nd message.

My guess is you panicked when you realised you had made a mistake by showing your hand. You decided to name PO as evil to try to push you back to 50/50

Yesterday you were 50/50 CTUHULUH was killed, proven as good and all of a sudden your a 0% HTF does that work

 

Because I am good.

I plea with my villagers... go for someone random. I nearly just pretended I was the backup seer as a desperate last measure to go for somebody random as at least you then have a shot at someone evil... but I don't want to confuse things when you see I'm good.

 

Those left today: 12 (Could be 9 in worse case scenario come tomorrow)

Otter
Hornetgags
Meh
NorwayHornet
With A Smile
Miked2006
Optimistichornet
PowerJugs
Daft Row
Steve Leo Beleck
BigRossLittleRoss
PhillipineOrn

Still yet to comment today:

Hornetgags
Optimistichornet

 

I agree, we all need to stick together today; but that doesn't exonerate PO who may be in the spot light on him.

 

Can any of you alive people see the sub section 'werewolf the forum game' and the graveyard thread within it?

Nothings been posted in there at all, but just want to know before the dead go and chat about their views!

 

Well I guess thats just a lovely coincidence for the wolf and it's great that you've decided to jump on it... as I say conjecture! I respect that PO and I right now are nothing like a 50/50 choice... you have to go for me. I'm just hoping for a miracle. Promise you're all making the wrong decisaion if you lynch me.

 

TBF it was roughly 50:50 based on two evil messages.

 

I can see it.

On the other issue, can we wait until Monday to resume? I'm pretty sure that's what's always been done.

 

Yes

And I don't mind waiting til Monday if others want to.

 

Yeah, I was going to post that. We all need a break and will probably have plans.

This is the sort of game which you play at work, makes time go by quicker.