Day 4

Banter

 

I think Opti said he'd be busy this afternoon/evening so I'll do the honours in the voting thread.

Do you want to keep discussing things, or do you want me to just go ahead and reveal.

 

Reveal

 

Stretch it out

 

Kill kill kill

 

Nothing more to discuss today! Lynch him!

 

Lynch now!

 

If we are going to lynch him and close today i am happy to share who I believe is in team evil and give reasons just in case I am killed tonight

 

BLOOD FOR THE BLOOD GODS!

Reveal, but leave it open for discussion til 8pm if that's OK re: rules.

 

Kill him

 

Oi, less of this. Please.

 

Bit late to give ( another ) **** isn't it

 

Could suffocate him with PJ s duvet that he shat on .

 

Unfortunately, once I close the day phase by announcing the lynch, the night phase starts. And so it's unfair to allow everyone to discuss, because technically, one of you could be getting eaten and still having a bearing on the game by expressing your opinion, if you get my drift.

 

I'd wait for rest to say and wait for WaS to say as to whether he wants to chance it or not.

 

I'll be posting the result in 20 minutes. Reactions are allowed but discussions aren't!

 

Nothing more to discuss really .

It's all speculation until we have confirmation of DR canine nocturnal activities

 

You can do what you want in that 20 mins.

 

Now or never. It's your call.

 

OK I'll post my thoughts of team evil now then

BRLR - hasn't voted for Daft Row until today and after he had been condemned. very quiet on days 1 and 2, has suggested we can't believe todays message re who is good
Norway - Again hadn't voted for DR before today, again after he was condemned to blend in. Has tried to claim he doesn't understand the game particularly well and thats why he has been confused over roles and messages.

I have one other suspect, but nothing strong to go by

 

Can it be NSFW?

 

Big mark against BRLR is that he voted against Cthulhu. It was a tough call but it was ultimately the wrong call. Whether he knew if Daft Row was a Wolf only he knows as it was a 50/50.

NorwayHornet has constantly tried to second guess anything I've put out, some of which reasonable and some of it seemingly less so after it's been agreed with others and causes us to double check and potentially doubt our thoughts.

Hornetsgags has generally been very quiet.

None of these are strong indicators by themselves but it's interesting to see I'm not the only one thinking this re: BRLR and NorwayHornet.

That said, as it stands only Me and Opti are confirmed good so all bets are off. I have my hunches but can't back anything up.

Who's the suspect you're thinking of?

 

Only quiet on day 1 as I was observing, it being my first game. Very active on day 2 onwards. Also although I voted late I was condemning him from first thing this morning, went back to bed after that as I'd been up watching the election. Many people haven't voted for DR until today.

Thought it was interesting that PO was named as I had suspected since day 1

 

I mentioned him on one of the other days. I don't want to say because apart from a feeling that he is part of team evil i don't have a lot to go on.

The way they have played the game they could easily have a influential role in team good

 

8 people voted for Cthulhu yesterday , not really a black mark as I gave a very detailed logical account why which SteveLeo also came up with.

 

It's why I called it a 50/50 and that nothing is a strong indicator in of itself.

 

I came up with a reasoning why Cthulhu was a bit more than 50% chance wolfy but obviously he could well have been the tinker anyway, so I think we're none the wiser (until Harrow tells us at the end of it all).

 

A good wolf always hides in the shadow of others

I think you managed to avoid voting on day 1 as well ? You could have done that while you were watching the game

Everyone voted for EddieC, you could easily have hidden in there, rather than waiting for us to start to analysis the voting patterns

 

2 questions re rules

1- can the masons be described as very good or is it just , seer, guardian and witness
2- PJ mentioned that when visiting you will die if you visit an evil , but why would you die if you visited traitor ? Sure,y just the wolfs

 

PJ agree with s lot you have said especially later on ,once I got over suspicion of your role , I mean aren't harlots by nature evil ,from a biblical sense at least.

I as I have mentioned thanks to this afternoons trawl have got it narrowed down to 3 or 4 ,assuming DR is lupinewhich I hope is 99.99% nailed on

 

Before masons were just labelled as good

 

100%

 

I was described as Good when eaten by a Wolf last time. Played as a Mason!

Traitor feeds me to them.

 

If I was hiding in the shadows then I would have just voted for Eddie c like every else . I didn't because I didn't start observing game till it was too late .

I must say I find your continual suspicion of me on such spurious evidence a little suspicious. Possibke traitor trying to turn people against another good villager perhaps although your low level of posting may imply not.

 

Correct re: Biblical standpoint, but not to Werewolf. (awoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo)