WFC Elimination Game

**wfcthroughandthrough** · 03-06-2012, 05:40 PM

Loach = 1 to many mistakes and failed to deal with pressure
Hodson = 4 had a fantastic season, often unsung, kept expirianc eplayers out of the side and didn't look out of place
Dickinson = 1
Eustace = 4
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 4
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5
Iwelumo = 3
Forsyth = 3
Doyley = 3
Jenkins = 0 - Truly awful. Good luck to him, but seriously, how is he still at the club?!
Bennett = 3
Buaben = 3
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 10 - What a second half to the season.
Garner = 0
Hogg = 5
Nosworthy = 5

**Optimistichornet** · 03-06-2012, 06:16 PM

Loach = 1
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 1
Eustace = 4
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 4
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5
Iwelumo = 3
Forsyth = 3
Doyley = 3
Jenkins = ELIMINATED
Bennett = 3
Buaben = 3
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 10
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 5
Nosworthy = 5

competition heating up, murray has a sizeable advantage at this point.

**sonofben** · 03-06-2012, 07:32 PM

Loach = 2 Think we are being a bit rough on him, would rather have him then most keepers at this level
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 1
Eustace = 4
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 3 Likely to be an ex-Watford player soon any way
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5
Iwelumo = 3
Forsyth = 3
Doyley = 3
Jenkins = ELIMINATED
Bennett = 3
Buaben = 3
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 10
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 5
Nosworthy = 5

**NemoNemo** · 03-06-2012, 07:55 PM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 1
Eustace = 4
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 3
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 6 Has earned his title as Watford's main goal threat and top scorer. Top work rate and all round game is fantastic
Iwelumo = 3
Forsyth = 2 Doesn't have any competition for the left wing position and still cant get in the team. Poor in possession and can't track back at all
Doyley = 3
Jenkins = ELIMINATED
Bennett = 3
Buaben = 3
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 10
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 5
Nosworthy = 5

**oxhey67** · 03-06-2012, 07:58 PM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 1
Eustace = 4
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 4 I've enjoyed watching him play since his debut and he's a leader among men both on & off the pitch. A class act at Championship level.
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 6
Iwelumo = 3
Forsyth = 2
Doyley = 3
Jenkins = ELIMINATED
Bennett = 3
Buaben = 3
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 9 He's good but expectations already seem unrealistic by supporters. Nowhere near the finished article & I hope fans remember this when he has a dodgy spell next season.
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 5
Nosworthy = 5

**Hornmeister** · 03-06-2012, 08:26 PM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 1
Eustace = 4
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 4
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 6
Iwelumo = 3
Forsyth = 2
Doyley = 4 No reasdon required
Jenkins = ELIMINATED
Bennett = 1 Should have broken through this season
Buaben = 3
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 5
Nosworthy = 5[/QUOTE]

**Optimistichornet** · 03-06-2012, 08:47 PM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 1
Eustace = 5 captain fantastic
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 4
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 6
Iwelumo = 3
Forsyth = 1 struggled to make a breakthrough this year, one for the future
Doyley = 4
Jenkins = ELIMINATED
Bennett = 2
Buaben = 3
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 5
Nosworthy = 5

**simms** · 03-06-2012, 09:31 PM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 1
Eustace =5
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 4
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 6
Iwelumo = 3
Forsyth =1
Doyley = 5 Legend
Jenkins = ELIMINATED
Bennett = 1 didn't play much
Buaben = 3
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 5
Nosworthy = 5

**YellowKicks** · 03-06-2012, 09:36 PM

Bennett should be on 0 and eliminated

**Ghost of Barry Endean** · 03-06-2012, 09:56 PM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 1
Eustace =6 even when he's not on the field his influence on the side shines through
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 4
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5 - sorry, not convinced - works his ass off but should have had at least 20 if he had scored the sitters that he fluffed
Iwelumo = 3
Forsyth =1
Doyley = 5 Legend
Jenkins = ELIMINATED
Bennett = 1 didn't play much
Buaben = 3
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 5
Nosworthy = 5

**Optimistichornet** · 03-06-2012, 10:30 PM

Originally Posted by YellowKicks

Bennett should be on 0 and eliminated

no he isnt. he is on two, only meister and simms have taken points off him, he is on 1.

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 1
Eustace =6
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 4
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5
Iwelumo = 3
Forsyth =1
Doyley = 5
Jenkins =ELIMINATED
Bennett = 1
Buaben = 3
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 5
Nosworthy = 5

**JLuck16** · 04-06-2012, 12:24 AM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 1
Eustace =6
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 4
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5
Iwelumo = 3
Forsyth = 1
Doyley = 5
Jenkins =ELIMINATED
Bennett = 0 - played exceptionally against WHU and showed great potential, but only played once
Buaben = 3
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 6 - exceeded expectation, incredibly consistent in his first full season playing, very good all-round player
Nosworthy = 5

P.S. Jenkins isn't 'truly awful'!

**Optimistichornet** · 04-06-2012, 12:32 AM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 1
Eustace =6
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 4
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5
Iwelumo = 3
Forsyth = 1
Doyley = 5
Jenkins =ELIMINATED
Bennett = ELIMINATED
Buaben = 2 (struggled to break up the eustace and hogg partnership this season)
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 6
Nosworthy = 6 (most important signing of the season, made the defence very solid and contributed with a few goals)

**JLuck16** · 04-06-2012, 12:49 AM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 1
Eustace =6
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 5 - Best player. Legend
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5
Iwelumo = 3
Forsyth = 0 - Still learning and raw, but had to go from the list left
Doyley = 5
Jenkins =ELIMINATED
Bennett = ELIMINATED
Buaben = 2
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 6
Nosworthy = 6

**The Voice of Reason** · 04-06-2012, 12:59 AM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 2 does not deserve to be elliminated
Eustace =6
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 5
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5
Iwelumo = 2 to little to late, time to go
Forsyth = 0
Doyley = 5
Jenkins =ELIMINATED
Bennett = ELIMINATED
Buaben = 2
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 6
Nosworthy = 6

**J.B** · 04-06-2012, 01:32 AM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 2
Eustace =6
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 5
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5
Iwelumo = 3 - Disgustingly treated by so called supporters when he first came here but just got his head down and got about his job showing that he does a good job for the team and can be a very useful player for us.
Forsyth = 0
Doyley = 5
Jenkins =ELIMINATED
Bennett = ELIMINATED
Buaben = 2
Mirfin = ELIMINATED (-1) - He really has been that pointless
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 6
Nosworthy = 6

Honourable mentions have to go to Deeney and Loach as well, Loach mainly because he has been nowhere near as bad as people have made out.

**Estuary Hornet** · 04-06-2012, 09:19 AM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 2
Eustace =6
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 5
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5
Iwelumo = 4- Very useful as an impact player and has been very badly treated this season, someone I want to see playing next season
Forsyth = 0
Doyley = 5
Jenkins =ELIMINATED
Bennett = ELIMINATED
Buaben = 1- Maybe he needs to adjust to championship football but from what I've se, he's just so lightweight
Mirfin = ELIMINATED (-1)
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 6
Nosworthy = 6

Bennett has been dealt with very harshly on here. It is difficult to break into the team when you have Maps and Nosworthy at central defence with Martin Taylor on the bench, Maps didn't break into the first team until his twenties so we will see. Forsyth I can see being a very good player in the future. Yeates is rubbish.

**Nnnn** · 04-06-2012, 09:36 AM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 2
Eustace =6
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 4 2.5 Mill? Yes please.
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5
Iwelumo = 4
Forsyth = o
Doyley = 5
Jenkins =ELIMINATED
Bennett = ELIMINATED
Buaben = 2 - He has the ability to link up with the strikers, something no other central midfielder at the club currently has. Looks decent, I've no idea why some fans have started on him.
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 6
Nosworthy = 6

**frontrowrook** · 04-06-2012, 10:02 AM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 4
Dickinson = 1 I like the passion Dicko shows and he has had some good games. Had Forsyth not have been eliminated already I would deduct him a life. Out of the remaining players Dicko is has had the worst season, very inconsistent.
Eustace =6
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 5 It was quite obvious he would win player of the season so how he hasn't got more lives than ths is way beyond me! I think Murray is fantastic and is some prospect but Mapps has been incredible this season!
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5
Iwelumo = 4
Forsyth = 0
Doyley = 5
Jenkins =ELIMINATED
Bennett = ELIMINATED
Buaben = 2
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 6
Nosworthy = 6

**The Voice of Reason** · 04-06-2012, 10:24 AM

Loach = 2
Hodson = 3 A good young lad, but needs a little more strength.
Dickinson = 2 I disagree with the last poster other current survivors had a worst season than Dicko
Eustace =6
Taylor = 3
Mariappa = 5 It was quite obvious he would win player of the season so how he hasn't got more lives than ths is way beyond me! I think Murray is fantastic and is some prospect but Mapps has been incredible this season!
Yeates = ELIMINATED
Deeney = 5
Iwelumo = 4
Forsyth = ELMINATED
Doyley = 5
Jenkins =ELIMINATED
Bennett = ELIMINATED
Buaben = 2
Mirfin = ELIMINATED
Murray = 9
Garner = ELIMINATED
Hogg = 6
Nosworthy = 6

Thread: WFC Elimination Game

Thread Tools

Display

Posting Permissions