This is just an observation , no more . But HH you seem to be defending SLB quite a lot more than I would expect . It seems strange you are protecting an outed harlot so vehemently at the cost of other good villagers being lynched. Like I say , just an impression , and probably nothing in it .
HH24 is defending SLB because the facts make it unlikely that he's the wolf, read my post #56 from yesterday where I broke the logic down. I've voted Grrwood, based on the fact that we have nothing else to go on regarding him. The vote was somewhat reluctant because I don't think that the seer has done us any favours today with the style that he wrote his message.
14 players left 3 evil players (assuming only one traitor) 11 good players One player lynched tonight If that player is evil, tomorrow we have potentially 10 good players vs 2 evil (assuming lynched player is a wolf & only 1 overnight good killed) Or: 9 good players vs 2 evil (assuming evil lynched is traitor & 2 good killed overnight) If the lynched player is good, we are left with 8 good vs 3 evil (1 good player lynched & 2 good killed overnight) If SLB is telling the truth and is the harlot at some point it will be worth him revealing who he's stayed with. If he successfully stays with a good player tonight and survives, that point may be tomorrow if a good player is lynched tonight. Excluding Cassetti's Beard, SLB will know 3 good players by then. With only 8 good players left, that means half (including SLB) can be revealed. The fuller picture of possible evils may then be clearer and it may be more obvious who the Seer should view.* If, though, we lynch an evil tonight I would suggest SLB keeps quiet as team good would still be in the driving seat. *This obviously on assumption that SLB is telling the truth about being the harlot
Otter, why keep throwing my name into the mix without anything to back it up ? I keep asking you to come up with good reasons but you just seem to be ignoring me. However I do agree that today's only real option is Grrwood.
Happy, I'm also out later to watch daughter's school play or concert or something. I'm assuming its not the same play (or daughter)
Been looking at the timings of the messages to see if there is any consistencies. Day 1: Message 1 - 9:27am Message 2 - 1:54pm Day 2: Message 1 - 9:14am Message 2 - 10:00am Day 3: Message 1 - 9:10am Message 2 - 9:15am Day 4: Message 1 - 10:22am Message 2 - 11:12am Nothing overly obvious stands out except maybe the consistent early Message 1's!
Sorry sorry! I got confused about today's message! Dom is innocent and was named by the seer today. I am so bad at this game even when all I have to do is vote
Ha! Is your daughter a 10 year old playing "Miss Honey" in "Matilda"? If so, hello husband, had no idea you were a member on here
It would be unwise for SLB to reveal who he's stayed with, not so much for any ordinary villagers but if he'd stayed with the seer that could be devastating. Instead towards the end of the day why doesn't SLB name 1 or 2 players he wouldn't dare risk staying with? Re NW Orn, I stated yesterday that your posting frequency along with your voting pattern why you were on my radar. All I've suggested is for the seer to have a look; yes I voted for you yesterday because I refused to vote for SLB because I am confident that he's good and I put my X where my mouth was.
True. I had thought that about the Seer (or Guardian). Tomorrow may be too early but, if evil continue to decimate us, there will be a point where the risk will be worth it. The trouble is, with the wolves knowing each other's identities, they have pretty much free reign every night to take out two good players. (I know they might eat the traitor accidentally but that doesn't matter as much as eating another wolf)
I'm scared to stay at a lot of people's houses Otter to be honest - the ones I think are evil AND the ones I think are so obviously good that they might get munched. Bit of a rubbish situation as it forces me towards staying with those I'm not sure about! The only ones I know for definite as Good, I've already stayed there so can't go back. It's the curse of being a dirty stop out.
@Harrow Orn - Are wolf and seer only allowed to send ONE message per day? Or can they send a second if they wish to do so..?
Fair enough, but who would you least likely pay a visit? I'm not looking for a reason why, just interested.
No she's a an 11 year old playing a downtrodden wife in a some play set in Tennessee. Mrs NW Orn did tell me the name but I mustn't have been listening. Isn't Mr Happy an egg and chipper ?
It seems Grr is going to be lynched. I dont think its him, defo not Traitor.... possibly wolf not likley. My suspicions lie elsewhere. I have an idea who the Traitor might be but I dont want to act on it as it is only that, a suspicion. I fear we lynching a good one again but Im going to go with the flow this time and vote Grr unless a counter argument arises this afternoon.
There's not really another choice annoyingly - If someone else was in my position I'd be voting for them. Team Evil has done brilliantly leaving no other obvious leads for 4 days. We can rule out Dom thanks to the seer, but really we could have done with some of the people throwing wild accusations being viewed. I would suggest WAS or Otter for tomorrow, Seer.
Interesting vote from dom, Grrwood being evil just doesn't sit right. PJ certainly worth a look from the seer tomorrow though.
I am concerned that the wolf may well have highlighted Grrwood as an evil because he knows a couple of us had highlighted him as being "on our radar". But I don't see what else we can do, bar lynching SLB which I'm reluctant to do.
Well he's innocent so knows his message is from the seer and mine is from the wolf so makes sense really. I still think it's either PJ, WAS or possibly you!
Sadly the witch hunt started by WAS put me in the spotlight, the wolf has jumped on the back of it. Understand there's not really anything else to do than to make sure!
Grrwood, I would hardly say a witch hunt. On day 1 I made my first vote and then explained why on day 3 and again today. What i don't understand is what has stopped you putting up any sort of argument for defending yourself with some sort of evidence or reason
Been inundated with work today, so been much less active than usual. Not surprisingly it makes me look suspicious so fair enough as it's different behaviour from usual self. Even lunch break was cut short. I'd be disinclined to vote Grrwood if we had something else to go on but what other choice do we have?
It's difficult to put up reasonable arguments to stupid, nonsensical accusations! "They all mentioned that the wolves know each other now, they must be evil!" Get a grip. If you're a good player you've helped lose this game. If you're traitor, well played steering everyone down dead ends based on nonsense.
I had PJ, HH24 and Norway as a pack after night 1's reveal. On day 2 I had Steve Harrow and Cthulhu as Norways team. Followed the other voters on those days but wonder if any of those are right.
Voting With a Smile. Sorry if I'm wrong but can't get past your posts this morning: 1. Claiming not to be sure if the wolves know each other. 2. Writing that you'll be sure the wolves will "avoid each other like the plague" sounded like a warning to a fellow wolf not to engage with your posts and draw attention to your teamwork. 3. Encouraging the Seer to view me. It seems settled in most people's minds that I'm the Harlot, even Steve Harrow and BRLR thought that yesterday when they voted for me. Seems like an attempt to influence the Seer into wasting a viewing.
