DAY 6 - Werewolf 2018

Discussion in 'Werewolf: The forum game' started by Otter, Jun 11, 2018.

Tags:
?

Day 6 Lynching

Poll closed Jun 11, 2018.
  1. miked2006

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  2. NorwayHornet

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  3. Philippine Orn

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  4. PowerJugs

    50.0%
  5. steve harrow

    50.0%
  6. With A Smile

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Otter

    Otter Gambling industry insider

    The rain just didn't stop, but having left Squibba's emporium of death the remaining 8 villagers agreed to meet up at cthulhu's bar before sundown. They all arrived at more or less the same time. They say together at the largest table, all off them. They had a drink each and in the centre of the table was the guardian's silver sword. The only way the villagers could drink together at night was to watch each other.

    If anyone transformed the others would be able to attack. Optimistichornet sat with a pint in front of him yet he caressed the pistol he had in his hand, "Who needs a sword, when you have a f***ing cannon?", he reminded the others. The drank and were jovial together, despite the outstanding problem of there being a wolf among them, they were able to protect each other. Also the reason to celebrate was that they had lynched 3 evil men in 3 days. Outside the rain never stopped.

    Saturday morning arrived, one or two of the villagers were still drinking but most of the others were snoring in their seats. All 8 were still there, the silver sword lay untouched in the centre of the table. The gentlemen's agreement was that no one was going to play with it, it served a single purpose yet that purpose never took place that night. The alarm rang to wake the villagers, it was dawn, it was safe to return to their respective dwellings. The parting agreement was to meet in the same place that evening before sunset.

    Saturday evening soon arrived with most villagers still feeling the effects of the previous night. The clouds had gathered again, the rain started gently but soon got heavy again. The 8 villagers sat at the largest table once more, drinks and food were prepared but most importantly the sword remained in the centre, no-one was to touch it unless there was no choice. Optimistichornet again waved his pistol about, "She's a beauty, isn't she?" he would cajole the others. That night was more solemn than the previous one, the 8 had survived a night, no one rips to shreds, no one harmed. Now was a time of reflection, but the drinking continued. The octet carried on through the night, no one dare leave. If it wasn't for the fact that a wolf was among them the weather was horrendous, they were safe in numbers and dry.

    Soon Sunday came, the sword was still untouched, the 8 had got through another night. Was Squibba the last? No one was sure, could anyone take the risk? The concensus was to go home, sleep off the alcohol ans return again before dusk.

    Sunday night, now the 8 villagers seemed a bit more cheerful, despite the loss of so many good people they were safe. Maybe the sword didn't need to be used again? No one knew. The rain was still raging outside, the village was sodden. The 8 villagers raised their glasses and chanted out the names of the fallen over the last week, but they left the last to their most cherished heroine, HappyHornet24 was their saviour for so many days who had bravely stood in the line of fire for so long had laid her life down so they would live. Once again the sword was in the centre of the table. A third night drinking was starting to take its toll on the remaining villagers, but they carried on. Finally the rain stopped but it was still night and the revellers carried on.

    Monday morning arrived, PhilippineOrn woke up, still with a bottle in his hand. He scanned the scene, it was utter carnage, the drinking over the weekend was monumental. Steve harrow was still snoring, the sound was amplified by a traffic cone that was placed strategically over his head. The sword in the middle was still in the same place as before, it was never used; but as PhilippineOrn looked around the table he soon realised that it should have been. There opposite him was the headless body of Harrow Orn, the head was lying on its side on the table in front of the body, PhilippineOrn jumped back sending his chair clattering to the ground making such a racket that it woke the others apart from OptimisticHornet to his left, who he hadn't realised was lying in a pool of coagulated blood on the table, his pistol was on the floor behind the body and there was a hole in the back of his head. Stunned and sobering up at lightning speed the surviving 6 looked at each other, who had done this?

    Harrow Orn was (formerly VERY) GOOD
    OptimisticHornet
    was GOOD

    ========================================================================
    Remaining players:

    miked2006
    NorwayHornet
    Philippine Orn
    PowerJugs
    steve harrow
    With A Smile

    ========================================================================
    Former players

    Diamond - lynched Day 1
    cthulhu - killed Night 1
    Daft Row - lynched Day 2
    Steve Leo Beleck - killed Night 2
    wfcmoog - lynched Day 3
    Meh - killed Night 3
    domthehornet - killed Night 3
    nornironhorn - lynched Day 4
    Cassetti's Beard - killed Night 4
    HappyHornet24 - killed Night 4
    Squibba - lynched Day 5
    Harrow Orn - killed during weekend binge
    Optimistichornet - killed during weekend binge

    The village is open:

    I will not be around between 8:20am & 9am.

    The village will close after all 6 votes are in or 4pm which ever is sooner.

    As we are down to a few I would like to close by 4pm today and any messages to arrive before 2pm

    *** Final note: here's been 2 cases of non-voting but neither had been decisive, as of today no vote or no posts you will be killed off ***
     
  2. Otter

    Otter Gambling industry insider

    FYI I allowed the single remaining wolf to make 2 kills over the weekend as it will bring a result by tomorrow at the latest.
     
  3. PhilippineOrn

    PhilippineOrn First Team

    Ahhh bummer, I thought we had enough numbers on our side we could afford a mistake but not to be.

    Now that it's clear what the blood letting was about, we know somebody was good until Night 2, whereupon they became evil. Voting patterns are no longer helpful since days 3 and 4 (Moog and Norn) were unanimous foregone conclusions anyway.

    So we still have our pool of possible guilty: Norway; Mike; Steve; PJ and me.

    Since we cannot go by votes I have gone over all of their posts again. Did anybody change in any way or act differently after morning 3?

    The answer is not really. Honestly, the two only people that even vaguely stand out as suspicious are Opti and me. One or two have reacted in a mildly suspicious way but then again I was suspicious of HH at the beginning of the game.

    So (for me) only Norway, Mike, Steve and PJ are possible candidates. Not one of them, like I said has made a single remark that indefatigably incriminates themselves.

    So instead of looking at what they said I looked towards what others said, and where better to start with Squibba.

    He missed the best opportunity of saving the game for Evil by not posting a message as the back up seer but he was totally a deer in headlights when he came online so not surprising he didn't think that through. In his state of panic he also made three very telling statements:

    If it goes to be then I'm suspicious of how happy Mike was to vote me then jump on a plane and not have to deal with the fall out.


    Then

    Because how I see it right now I'm just as guilty as Steve & PJ on the low activity basis.

    Then in answering Opti's direct question of who he thinks is guilty replied with:

    Everyone but you and Harrow mate. Mostly Steve though.

    I am going to take a punt and say Squibba probably wouldn't go and name his apprentice when firing off Mike's, Steve's and PJ's names on his way out. Which just leaves me.

    Norway, you played a fairly good game, causing no controversy, accusing nobody, palling up with different players at different stages, I believe you must be our apprentice wolf. I'm open to hearing evidence I have missed.
     
  4. Norwayhornet

    Norwayhornet Squad Player

    Good reasoning PO but wrong I too have my ideas that I will expand on lat er as I am at the doctors again awaiting appointment in 10 mins or so .
    Briefly I was looking at some day 5 comments from Harrow to be clearer I need my laptop so I can give you post numbers as phone doesn't give post numbers .
     
  5. With A Smile

    With A Smile First Team

    god this is going to twist us even more

    I take it that Opti used his silver billet earlier in the week to protect himself then ?

    I'm also guessing that there was no back up seer, as we didn't get a message on Friday.
     
  6. steve harrow

    steve harrow Reservist

    2 known good dead? Aaargh. Still the one wolf though. I'd say let's not be led by a single accuser trying to have us lynch someone.
    We have a few hours to look over the votes and sine of the previous posts by folk like Happy. And think it's clear which messages are from the seer. The only caveat to that is Norway.
     
  7. With A Smile

    With A Smile First Team

    I have just looked back at what Opti's silver bullet was all about

    On day 3 pg 7 he says

    post 1
    I'm a gunslinger. I have a limited number of shots with a silver bullet. I had a daytime shot, and a night-time shot. I plan on using the night-time shot to protect myself in case of future wolf attacks, but thought I could help clear up the mess here today.

    post 2
    I thought about it, trust me. I was debating for a long time, but like I said my gun doesn't just hold one bullet and a full moon also brings a handy extra round. To be honest I was convinced Moog was good and wanted to try to save him from a lynching, but this has worked out just as well.

    So why didn't his silver bullet save him? - is that what the strike of lightening changed ?

    I can't see why Opti would have committed harri carri

    POINTLESS THEORY
    The only other thing in there is that he thought Moog was good and wanted to save him from a lynching. What if opti was bad and shot Harrow to save Moog ?
     
  8. steve harrow

    steve harrow Reservist

    Was Opti just bluffing about the second bullet to avoid attack?

    What's your pointless theory about? Opti was good.
     
  9. With A Smile

    With A Smile First Team

    Deeeerr - of course he was :(:(:(:(

    just looking to much into possibilities :(
     
  10. Norwayhornet

    Norwayhornet Squad Player

    ok here are a couple of my thoughts Day 5 post 102 , before Squibbas demise is Steve trying to protect him
    "Squibba I just don't know enough about. Being quiet doesn't mean you're a wolf but if confirmed good folk have enough doubt, I'm happy to go along with that. We are all guessing somewhat and the truth is I don't really have any idea!"

    Harrows post 110
    "
    On day 1 Squibba first posted at 12.42pm.
    On day 1 the wolfs message came to Otter at 12.47pm.

    With all the other reasons, and now this which I just looked back on, I have to vote squibba.

    Noted how Steve has responded to my question about Squibba by quite clearly sitting on the fence and not really answering my question. Happy to jump on the bandwagon, but wont lead a charge against anyone.

    If squibba is evil then Steve may his wolf friend.

    If squibba is good then fml etc."

    Also PO has acted a little weird what with his little spat , however I have a gut feeling PO is Good .

    As far as know Now the only one who is definitely good is WAS (assuming potioneers are good)
    Everyone else including me is potentially the Wolf , incidentally Mikes going on holiday would be a fantastic reason for a wolf not to post .

    Anyone else care to throw some more ideas in the mix PO and I have had our say .
     
  11. With A Smile

    With A Smile First Team

    I saved HH with a good potion when i knew that Harrow couldn't protect her.

    I've always been suspicious of PJ like steve comes and goes and as I said when i voted for him on Friday has sat on the fence throughout

    Could it be that Mike was the final wolf and knowing that he couldn't vote the lightening strike introduced a new wolf to take his place ?
    This could have been instead of a full moon when Opti would have gained an extra round of bullet(s)

    Surprised that PH thinks we had a back up seer on Friday, that was stuck in the headlights. why does he think we definitely had a back up seer ?
     
  12. PhilippineOrn

    PhilippineOrn First Team

    I didn't think we had a backup seer, I said Squibba missed a trick by not leaving a message posing as the back up seer. It was Squibba I said was like a deer in headlights.
     
  13. Norwayhornet

    Norwayhornet Squad Player

    I agree with PO if I would have been alpha I would have messaged as early as possible accused someone as evil then sat back whilst confusion reigned
    after no messages on friday ,I dont think there is a back up seer either , unless thats what that lightning bolt stuff is all about
     
  14. Norwayhornet

    Norwayhornet Squad Player

    Time to take the dog out ,I would like to hear PJs and Mikes opinions
     
  15. steve harrow

    steve harrow Reservist

    For me, there's only one declared good among us and everyone else is a suspect.

    Mike is an unknown. Norway is a funny one because he was declared good but if the wolf could choose who to turn, maybe they'd pick Norway because of that.

    Philippine I'm wary of and is probably higher on my list of possibles.

    Similarly with Power Jugs. Obviously I know I'm good but then everyone says that.

    With a Smile I'm happy to take as a confirmed good. I'm not sitting on the fence, I just don't know who is good and bad!
     
  16. PhilippineOrn

    PhilippineOrn First Team

    It's 5am in Barbados, guess we will have to wait a while on Mike.
     
  17. Otter

    Otter Gambling industry insider

    18 months ago we did Winter werewolf, I was in Lima at the time, also 5 hours behind the UK and I got accused of being quiet one morning!
     
  18. Otter

    Otter Gambling industry insider

    Anonymous Message #1 (received 10:10)

    Village now have me as back-up seer.

    Appointed weekend so no view/post Friday. Thought might post 1358 so wolf have no chance reply but worried backfire and people say like early message.

    Wolf might contradict/ignore this message.

    Friday votes mean viewed Power Jugs today. He GOOD.

    Confirmed Happy Hornet viewed Norway Hornet, Daft Row, WFCMoog and Nornironhorn.

    If I/we here tomorrow, probably view Philippine Orn. Or Norway Hornet to know for sure if still good.
     
  19. PhilippineOrn

    PhilippineOrn First Team

    If no other message arrives I guess that means that's our wolf.
     
  20. steve harrow

    steve harrow Reservist

    That's rather presumptuous.
     
  21. PhilippineOrn

    PhilippineOrn First Team

    You think? Wouldn't a backup seer (if we had one) be named immediately after HH was killed?
     
  22. Norwayhornet

    Norwayhornet Squad Player

    I think thats wolf ,normally a back up seer is nominated straight away , however this has been a game of surprises.
    that stuff appointed 1358 on friday so wolf couldnt respond , didnt we have a fair amount of overtime on friday ?
    I am sorry PJ but that message really doesnt help your cause .
     
  23. steve harrow

    steve harrow Reservist

    I guess the problem I have with your post is that if there is a back up seer now, you've already intimated there that the wolf doesn't need to respond and we all think that's their message. The only way you would know if that was the wolf's message is if you were the wolf or the possible back up seer.
     
    With A Smile likes this.
  24. steve harrow

    steve harrow Reservist

    It says "Appointed weekend so no view/post Friday".
     
  25. PhilippineOrn

    PhilippineOrn First Team

    I didn't say I knew it was the wolf's message...

    Are you going to come up with any theory or idea of your own or continue to speak a lot and say nothing?
     
  26. PhilippineOrn

    PhilippineOrn First Team

    Yes thank you, I can read what it says. BTW, it's Werewolf. Not every message is going to be completely honest.
     
  27. Norwayhornet

    Norwayhornet Squad Player

    Would be a great thing for a clever wolf to throw in to the mix .
     
  28. steve harrow

    steve harrow Reservist

    No point having a theory that has no basis in fact!

    If we say today's message is the wolf, PJ may or may not be good. It could be a bluff or just a wolf trying to get us to lynch PJ.

    If today's message is from a back up seer, PJ is good along with WAS.

    Attempts to state opinions as facts are always suspicious. And so your immediate post after the message (good or bad) puts you as my prime suspect now.
     
  29. With A Smile

    With A Smile First Team

    I think its interesting that the message has said who they were likely to view tomorrow, as well as today

    why would you do that as a seer ?
     
  30. PhilippineOrn

    PhilippineOrn First Team

    You're right, you win. Vote me and take the rest of the day off.
     
  31. Otter

    Otter Gambling industry insider

    Anonymous Message #2 (received 11:34)

    The earlier message is the wolf,the lightning bolt hit me I am now your Seer , I viewed our nice polite and august colleague PO .Guess
    what he is Good
     
  32. PhilippineOrn

    PhilippineOrn First Team

    Well that makes my choice easy. It's one or the other. Think VERY hard before you vote. Get it wrong, Evil wins.
     
  33. PhilippineOrn

    PhilippineOrn First Team

    ps I take objection to the sarcasm in that message! I am nice, polite and august!
     
    steve harrow likes this.
  34. steve harrow

    steve harrow Reservist

    Well that does make it interesting but it still doesn't mean one of PJ or PO are evil. I'm still leaning towards the latter given his reply to message 1 but that might be just a tad convenient for a wolf who knows both are good and doesn't care which gets lynched.

    This bloody game... I'd be a rubbish detective.
     
  35. steve harrow

    steve harrow Reservist

    If a good person gets lynched and then another killed tonight, it's still 2 good to 1 bad tomorrow?
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page